Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning (Easy DIY Recipe)

What is Montreal Steak Seasoning?

If you’ve ever wondered about that bold, peppery kick on your grilled meat, then you’re already familiar with Montreal Steak Seasoning. This iconic spice blend is a flavorful combination of coarsely ground black peppercorn, garlic powder, onion powder, and other vibrant spices that bring your steak from ordinary to unforgettable. The Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning version lets you replicate that zesty punch right at home without breaking the bank or running to the store.

This seasoning owes its fame to the original McCormick Grill Mates blend, revered for infusing steaks with robust, savory notes that dance on the palate. If you want to dive deeper into the history of this robust spice blend and its intriguing roots, checking out this article here might just ignite your culinary curiosity.

Popularity and Uses of McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning

What makes McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning so wildly popular? It’s the blend’s flexibility and that unmistakable flavor profile that appeals to meat lovers and home cooks alike. Beyond steak, it elevates burgers, adds zest to roasted veggies, and perks up sandwiches with a smoky, peppery boost. Fans of grilling swear by this signature blend from McCormick as their secret weapon, transforming every barbecue into a feast.

For those eager to perfect their steak grilling technique, this article on perfectly cooked steak every time is a fantastic companion to your seasoning adventures.

Ingredients in McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning Packets

Key Spices and Flavors

The magic behind the Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning lies in its carefully curated blend of spices. The cornerstone? Coarse black peppercorn that provides a sharp, lively heat. Complementing that is garlic powder and onion powder which add depth and savory richness. Then comes kosher salt, crucial for seasoning and balance, alongside hints of smoky paprika which lends a subtle earthiness.

These ingredients create the steak seasoning blend that delivers a robust, mouthwatering flavor with every sprinkle. If you ever find yourself wondering about substitutions or need inspiration, if you find you’re out of a key ingredient, exploring alternatives can keep your homemade packets fresh and exciting.

Additional Components in Packet Mix

Beyond the hallmark spices, the blend usually includes red pepper flakes to introduce a faint spicy warmth without overpowering the meat. Sometimes, coriander seeds or mustard seeds sneak in to give subtle aromatic accents, enriching the sensory experience.

When buying commercial mixes like the popular store-bought version of McCormick’s, you might notice these extra components help maintain consistency and shelf stability. However, creating your own mix means customizing to your taste and skipping additives you may prefer to avoid.

How to Make McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning Packets at Home

Gathering Ingredients and Tools

Before rolling up your sleeves, gather your ingredients:

  • Coarse black peppercorn
  • Garlic powder
  • Onion powder
  • Kosher salt
  • Smoked paprika
  • Red pepper flakes

You’ll also need basic kitchen tools:

  • Mortar and pestle or spice grinder (for coarser texture)
  • Measuring spoons
  • Mixing bowl
  • Airtight containers or small resealable bags for packets

Quality ingredients make a big difference, so pick fresh spices. Remember, the charm of homemade steak seasoning is in the freshness and control you have over your mixture.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Mixing the Spices

  1. Toast the peppercorns: For an intensified aroma, lightly toast black peppercorns in a dry pan for 1-2 minutes, shaking often so they don’t burn.
  2. Coarse grind peppercorns: Use a spice grinder or mortar and pestle to crush the toasted peppercorns until coarse — think pebble-sized, not powdery. This texture is key to that signature crunch and bite.
  3. Combine powders and flakes: In your mixing bowl, measure and mix the garlic powder, onion powder, kosher salt, smoked paprika, and red pepper flakes.
  4. Add the ground peppercorns: Stir the coarse pepper mixture into your bowl. Use a spoon or whisk to blend everything thoroughly.
  5. Taste test: Take a pinch and taste. If you crave more heat, sprinkle in extra red pepper flakes. Need a milder profile? Hold back on the pepper.

Article image

This process mimics another fantastic DIY spice blend and puts you in charge of crafting your own signature seasoning with every batch.

Packaging Tips for Seasoning Packets

Packaging your homemade spice packets right is just as important as mixing. Use small resealable bags or airtight jars to keep the seasoning fresh and ready to use. Label each packet with the date and contents — it helps keep your spice drawer organized!

For gifting or meal prep, consider portioning packets that match your typical steak size or recipe needs. This thoughtful portioning streamlines cooking time and keeps seasoning bursts consistent.

Storage and Shelf Life of Homemade Packets

Keep your seasoning packets well-sealed and stored in a cool, dry, and dark spot away from heat or moisture. Proper storage ensures the powerful aromas and flavors stay vibrant.

For detailed tips on spice preservation, see this guide on how to maximize the shelf life of your spices.

Generally, homemade packets last up to six months, but for best impact, use within three months.

How to Use McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning Packets

Marinating Steaks and Other Meats

Marinating with Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning is a game changer. Start by rubbing the seasoning generously on your steak, then drizzle with olive oil and a splash of vinegar or lemon juice to help flavors penetrate.

Let your meat soak for at least 30 minutes or up to 24 hours in the fridge. The spices tenderize while imparting that signature blend from McCormick zest. This method works beautifully for beef cuts, pork chops, and even robust fish like tuna.

For a deeper dive into marinating and grilling, check out our comprehensive guide to cooking the perfect steak.

Using Seasoning as a Dry Rub

If you’re short on time, applying the seasoning as a dry rub right before grilling or pan-searing packs an immediate punch. Just pat steak dry, coat liberally with the seasoning mix, and cook. The coarse texture creates a crust that locks in juices and gives that mouthwatering crunch.

This approach also shines on ribs, chicken, and roasted vegetables, proving the seasoning’s versatility beyond beef.

Other Creative Culinary Uses

The Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning isn’t just for meats. Sprinkle it over fries, popcorn, or roasted nuts for an addictive snack. Mix into sour cream or mayonnaise to whip up a zesty dipping sauce for even more flavor.

It’s perfect for putting your own spin on classic dishes, adding pop and personality with every sprinkle.

Tips and Tricks for Enhancing Your Homemade Montreal Steak Seasoning

Adjusting Spice Levels and Flavors

One of the best perks of homemade copycat seasoning mix is tailoring it to your heat tolerance. Want it smokier? Boost the smoked paprika. Prefer milder but flavorful? Dial back on the red pepper flakes.

Adding a bit of dried thyme or coriander can lend herbal notes that deepen complexity. Don’t hesitate to experiment in small batches until you find your perfect balance.

Pairing with Oils and Vinegars

For an upgraded marinade, try pairing it with a rich compound butter or mixing the seasoning with oils like avocado or flavored vinegar. These combinations help distribute flavors evenly and elevate your steak’s juiciness.

Learn how to enhance your steak even further with ideas from this article on Best Butter for Steak: Enhance Flavor with Compound Butters.

Combining with Other Seasonings

Mix your Montreal blend with a pinch of cumin or chili powder for a smoky, southwestern twist. Combining seasonings thoughtfully can open up new flavor horizons without losing the characteristic Montreal Steak Seasoning identity.

Benefits of Making Your Own Montreal Steak Seasoning Packets

Cost Savings Compared to Store-Bought

Buying pre-made packets can be convenient but often pricey. Crafting the Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning at home saves money by buying spices in bulk and customizing quantities. You skip preservatives and fillers too, making your packets fresher and more economical.

Customizing to Taste and Dietary Preferences

Homemade spice mixes empower you to control salt levels and omit allergens or additives. Whether you need low sodium or want an organic blend, making your own ensures it suits your diet and flavor preferences perfectly.

FAQs

What spices are in McCormick Montreal steak seasoning?
McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning features coarse black peppercorns, garlic powder, onion powder, kosher salt, smoked paprika, and red pepper flakes. These combine to create a bold, peppery, and smoky flavor profile cherished by steak lovers.

Can I make Montreal steak seasoning without peppercorns?
While black peppercorns are key for the signature bite, you can substitute with ground black pepper if needed, though coarse texture adds to the experience. If avoiding pepper altogether, experiment with additional garlic or smoked paprika for flavor depth.

How do I store homemade Montreal steak seasoning packets?
Store packets in airtight containers or resealable bags kept in cool, dark places away from moisture. Proper storage preserves aroma and potency. Refer to guidelines on how to keep your spices fresh for best practices.

Is Montreal steak seasoning spicy?
It offers moderate heat from red pepper flakes balanced with savory spices. It’s spicy enough to excite the palate without overwhelming—perfect for most taste buds, but adjustable when homemade.

Can Montreal steak seasoning be used on other meats besides steak?
Absolutely! The blend enhances pork, chicken, fish, and even vegetables. Its versatile flavor profile adapts well for dry rubs, marinades, and seasoning various dishes.

Conclusion

Making your own Copycat McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning packets at home is a simple, rewarding endeavor that brings personalized flavor and freshness to your meals. This DIY approach saves money by using pantry staples and allows you to tweak the Montreal steak seasoning recipe to your liking — whether that means dialing up the heat or creating a low-sodium blend.

With basic kitchen tools and quality spices, you can produce seasoning packets perfect for marinating, dry rubbing, and exploring creative culinary uses. Your homemade mix will give every steak, and more, that smoky, savory punch we all love. Ready to become your own grill mate? Start mixing and enjoy the savory adventures ahead!

For more ideas and techniques, check out these related reads: Montreal Steak Seasoning Substitute: 5 Easy Alternatives, Montreal Steak Seasoning Recipe: An Easy DIY Spice Blend, and explore Cowboy Butter Recipe: Zesty Sauce for Steak, Seafood & More to complement your seasoning perfectly.

Leave a Comment